Plane sailing: could Europe set a pattern for the rest of the world on aviation?

Posted by Dafydd Elis on January 22, 2009
EU, Mitigation

Transport Ministers from 21 major countries met in Tokyo last week to discuss the establishment of a global trading scheme for emissions from aviation. The ministers expressed their support for the International Civil Aviation Organisation’s (ICAO) efforts to take action on the growing contribution of the airline industry to the stock of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.

A global agreement on airline emissions would be an attractive prospect: it fits much more comfortably with the intercontinental, international nature of air travel. National or regional approaches are open to accusations of unfairness and even illegality from the airline industry. They are also more complex to implement because they have to find a way of dealing consistently with flights that depart from or arrive in countries not covered by the scheme.

Despite the limitations of regional initiatives, the EU has moved to bring airlines into its emissions trading scheme from 2012 onwards. The legislation – a new Directive amending the Directive that originally created the EU ETS – was approved last year.

Climatico

Emissions from the EU in 2006 by sector. Click to open larger version in a new window. Source: Climatico.

The chart on the right shows the EU’s CO2 emissions by sector. Emissions from aviation are shown by the red segment on the bar showing CO2 emissions from transport1. At first glance, it seems that emissions from airplanes are negligible, and indeed the airline industry contributes only around 3% of all European greenhouse gas emissions today. This is much less than emissions from road transport, and a small fraction of the emissions from the energy, manufacturing and construction sectors currently included in the EU ETS.

While the size of emissions from airplanes is currently fairly small, it has attracted attention because it is growing so quickly. During the period 2006-2020, emissions from air travel are forecast to more than double . The EU will be trying to reduce its emissions by 20% or possibly even 30% during the same period, so a 3% contribution today might translate into a figure closer to 8% by 2020.

As well as seeking to curb its own contribution to climate change, the EU may also be hoping to lead the way for the rest of the world by bringing aviation into a cap-and-trade system. The ICAO’s discussions are in relatively early stages, and it is unclear if and when it will reach an agreement over global emissions from the industry. Following the ICAO’s meeting last week, it was reported that the President of the ICAO’s Council believes that the EU’s approach might form a starting point for a worldwide emissions trading scheme for airplanes.

1 Planes contribute other greenhouse gases besides CO2, so strictily speaking looking at CO­2­ alone gives only a rough indication of the scale of GHG emissions from aviation.

Related posts:

  1. EU looks to the rest of the world at Bonn
  2. The new market in EU aviation allowances – trouble ahead?
  3. Aviation and the EU ETS: Who Administers the Expansion?
  4. Aviation’s Copenhagen Commitment
  5. Europe sets out its stall at the beginning of 2009

Tags: , , , ,

Make a Donation

Like what you read? Climatico is a nonprofit organization and relies on donations from readers like you to continue to provide you with quality independent coverage. Help show your support and make a tax-deductible donation today.

Comments


  • [...] requiring all countries to develop adaptation strategies, bringing international shipping and aviation into the scope of the international agreement, and a dramatic increase in energy research and [...]

    February 07 2009
    CommentsLike

    • [...] that of the global aviation industry- contributing approximately 2% of global CO2 emissions (Related Climatico blog- aviation emissions). However, the main conclusions of the report were more positive–noting “ICT’s largest [...]

      January 27 2009
      CommentsLike
      • Dafydd Elis

        Simon,

        I agree it’s an interesting question, but it’s one that I don’t think I’m qualified to answer! All I know of what the ICAO is the limited material that I’ve read on their website. From this documentation it looks as if discussions are still at a fairly preliminary stage even though they’ve officially been under way for a few years now. So I’m not sure that things are advanced enough to know how a global cap-and-trade scheme for aviation might eventually pan out, but that’s possibly just a reflection of my own lack of familiarity with the ICAO’s work.

        Dan,

        Thanks for the extra information on the UK: the 3% figure is an average figure for Europe and as you hint, it relates to GHG emissions not the overall forcing. I imagine there must be quite a spread within the EU27 with a relatively large amount of aviation emissions coming from countries with big international hub airports, like the UK and the Netherlands.

        January 23 2009
        CommentsLike
        • Dan

          In terms of the contribution of aviation – I think for the UK the contribution is about 6% before radiative forcing, which could more than double the global warming impact (a government estimate puts the contribution of aviation to UK emissions at 13% – http://www.theyworkforyou.com/wrans/?id=2007-05-02c.134036.h). And even 3% is pretty big chunk of emissions to think about. Plus, from an ethical perspective, if you fly then your own carbon footprint is likely to be far bigger than average.

          On the trading system – I’d imagine it would have to be integrated with cap and trade from other sectors. The EC is giving aviation a pretty stingy allocation, which would be difficult to comply with if they were not able to move the reductions into other industries. So I’d imagine that any international agreement will end up with the UNFCCC because they need to integrate with other sectors.

          January 23 2009
          CommentsLike
          • Simon Billett

            Would the ICAO’s indication that the EU ETS system could be a model for a global scheme (coupled with its role in bringing together international aviation) potentially make it the ‘host’ or ‘manager’ of a global system, do you think? Or is aviation likely to be built into a wider UNFCCC system? Highly speculative, I realise, but an interesting thought in the light of increasing discussion about the UNFCCC legal process not serving all climate change needs.

            January 23 2009
            CommentsLike